Hamilton Herald Masthead


Front Page - Friday, April 28, 2023

Our first freedoms: A look at the First Amendment

Inarguably the most important responsibility of the federal judiciary is to interpret and apply the United States Constitution. And as they affect the ordinary citizen, the first 10 amendments to the Constitution are the most important.

These amendments – the Bill of Rights – were demanded by framers who feared the proposed Constitution posed a risk to the rights of ordinary citizens. These proponents were concerned about concentrated power in a central government and insisted on explicit protections for individual liberty in the proposed Constitution.

The first freedoms – the First Amendment

Of the Bill of Rights, the First Amendment applies most often to the ordinary citizen today. Originally proposed as the third of 12 amendments, our First Amendment was one of the 10 ultimately adopted.

This amendment contains five specific freedoms: freedom of speech, freedom of religion, freedom of the press, freedom of assembly and the right to petition the government for redress of grievances.

Many Americans consider these five freedoms our most important, and not just for their placement as the first freedoms in the Bill of Rights. They are sometimes described as the rights of conscience – the rights to hold and express our own ideas and convictions, regardless of their uniqueness or popularity.

They are also the rights that allow us to organize and advocate for change when we believe change is needed.

Americans are unfamiliar with rights contained in First Amendment

Most Americans know they have freedom of speech, freedom of religion and the right to peacefully assemble. But many Americans are not aware that these critical rights have their basis in the First Amendment.

The most recent Annenberg Public Policy Center Annual Civics Knowledge Survey, released Sept. 13 shows that a disappointing number of Americans can identify the rights specified in the First Amendment unprompted.

Freedom of speech was identified by 63% of the respondents, down from 74% in 2021 and 73% in 2020

Freedom of religion was identified by 24%, down from 56% in 2021 and 47% in 2020

Freedom of the press was named by 20%, down from 50% in 2021 and 42% in 2020

Freedom of assembly was named by 16%, down from 30% in 2021 and 34% in 2020

The right to petition the government was named by 6%, down from 20% in 2021 and 14% in 2020

One of four respondents (26%) could not name any of the rights

Federal courts protect fundamental freedoms even when unpopular

Federal courts at all levels regularly handle cases brought by individuals seeking protection or redress under the First Amendment.

A case might involve a citizen alleging that a government entity is preventing her from voicing her opinions, or a religious entity alleging that a state or municipality is preventing its members from practicing their religion in the manner they desire, or a person alleging that the government is punishing him for his association with a disfavored group or organization.

Or it might involve a governmental entity trying to prevent the dissemination of an embarrassing or distasteful publication.

It’s often the case that popular opinion is in favor of the government action. The grievant might be a member of a minority group, a minority religion, or an adherent of a minority belief or philosophy.

The role of the federal courts is not to follow popular opinion but rather to adhere to the Constitution. In this way, our first freedoms, regardless of fickle public opinion or shifting political winds, are always protected.

Curtis L. Collier

U.S. district judge

Chair, Eastern District of Tennessee Civics and Outreach Committee

Carrie Brown Stefaniak

Law clerk to the Hon. Curtis L. Collier

Past president, Chattanooga Chapter of the Federal Bar Association

Karen L. Sheng

Law clerk to the Hon. Curtis L. Collier