The aromatic and flavorful cuisine of the land of the olive tree awaits us in this installment of Food FAQ as we explore a new Greek dining experience in Chattanooga.
Oh! Did you visit Zeekz House of Gyros, the new casual spot on North Market Street?
Nope. Been there; done that. I gave it an enthusiastic thumbs-up in the Herald’s Oct. 16 issue.
Then you must have eaten at Metropolis Chattanooga, the new family-owned Greek and Mediterranean restaurant, also on Market Street.
Um, no. I actually …
There’s Taziki’s Mediterranean Cafe, but it’s been a Greek go-to on Market Street for well over a decade. What else is out there?
More than you know. While locals might be tempted to call Market Street Chattanooga’s Little Athens, there are Greek restaurants elsewhere. I’ll be offering my thoughts about Nick the Greek, a fast-casual chain from California that’s opened a spot on Manufacturers Road, less than half a mile from Zeekz.
That’s crazy. How much Greek cuisine does one city need?
Can you have too many good Tex-Mex places? I’d argue no. And I’d say the same goes for great Greek food. Let’s dig in.
I’m ready. And suddenly hungry. I hope it’s good.
The menu is certainly impressive. Located in the Signal Mill complex alongside Edley’s Bar-B-Que, Mean Mug and Woof Gang Bakery, Nick the Greek offers one of the most diverse menus among its fast-casual Greek competitors.
As expected, pitas and gyros (pronounced “gee-rows” at Nick’s, a cashier informed me) abound. I’ll spare you the eye strain and list only a few options, including a beef and lamb blend, chicken, pork, veggie, falafel and steak.
The menu also features bowls, plates, salads, sides and desserts.
As I scanned the menu board during my first visit, I knew I was in trouble. While Nick’s doesn’t quite offer the Greek equivalent of the classic, 11-by-25-inch, tri-fold Tex-Mex menu, there’s still an impressive variety of dishes to consider.
For someone who believes Five Guys has the ideal number of choices (two: hamburger or hot dog), and who sometimes orders not because I’ve made a decision but because I can feel the cashier becoming impatient, this can be overwhelming.
Worse, everything sounded good and looked even better, thanks to the mouthwatering photos on the menu board.
After taking a breath, I managed to narrow my choices to three: the traditional beef and lamb gyro, the lamb burger and the Prasini salad.
When you’re gauging how good a restaurant is, you start with the basics. So, I went with a beef and lamb gyro and an order of fries.
How were they?
Here’s where the winds shift slightly. While there’s no arguing the food at Nick’s looks great, I did experience several niggles as I sampled various dishes.
The beef and lamb gyro was tasty, but I couldn’t help comparing it to the one at Zeekz, which I enjoyed more. The fries were well-seasoned and topped with delicious, crumbled feta, but they’d cooled to room temperature by the time they reached my table.
I’m low-key disappointed.
I was, too. Hoping for a better experience, I returned and tried the Prasini salad. My expectations were high. Not only had the picture won me over, but my eyes widened when it arrived in a bowl much larger than I’d expected, sporting a beautiful mound of crisp-looking romaine lettuce topped with crumbled feta and a glistening lemon zest dressing.
Digging in, I unearthed generous portions of chopped scallions and banana peppers.
See? It even sounds delicious. And it was – to a point. The lettuce was as fresh as I’ve ever tasted, the dressing added just enough tang to let you know it was there, and the feta provided a welcome salty kick.
But I wound up pushing aside what I thought would be my favorite ingredient – the banana peppers – because they’d been chopped but not properly prepped, leaving tough stems in my salad.
On my second visit, I also opted for a bottled drink, as the iced tea and fountain soda I’d tried and discarded during my first visit had an unpleasant taste that reminded me of unfiltered tap water.
I ordered a chicken kabob with my salad, too. It was perfectly cooked but underseasoned.
Maybe it was underseasoned for you.
Agreed. And that’s why Nick the Greek deserves a chance. There’s plenty to like, from the expansive menu and appealing presentation to the freshness of the ingredients. But the execution doesn’t always live up to the promise. I hope the staff will welcome the feedback and iron out the wrinkles.
Did any of the food land squarely in the plus column?
I’d say the froyo. Made with Greek frozen yogurt and topped with honey and crumbled baklava, it was delicious, with a combination of flavors and textures I found distinctive. My wife and I demolished the one pictured in the photo.
Given my love for Greek cuisine, I’ll give them a shot. I’m a completist.
Then prepare to be busy. I haven’t even mentioned Olos, the new addition to the Embassy Suites downtown. Its menu draws on Greek, Italian, Spanish and Turkish cuisine, making it Mediterranean rather than exclusively Greek. But it belongs in the conversation.
Then there’s OPA Greek Restaurant, an established eatery that’s expanding to 417 Frazier Avenue, and Santorini Spoon, a Greek frozen yogurt and sorbet shop expected to open in West Village in December.
Maybe we should just call all of downtown and the North Shore “Little Athens.”
Óntos!